Tuesday, November 17

No Woman Is An Island – Traverse Theatre

So, we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past

F. Scott Fitzgerald’s closing words from The Great Gatsby seem an appropriate introduction to No Woman Is an Island, a remarkable piece of theatre in which the voices of women through history wash over a solitary performer, their words carried forward, reinterpreted and transformed into something entirely new.

Written and performed by Róisín Stack, with performance direction by Ann Blake, this extraordinary one-woman show arrives at Edinburgh’s Traverse Theatre following its acclaimed Irish performances. It is an exquisitely constructed hour of theatre, combining philosophical reflection, personal revelation, visual artistry and wonderfully understated comedy.

There is something here for everybody. For the many in the audience who laugh enthusiastically at the philosophical quotations, perhaps eager to demonstrate their intellectual appreciation, and for those who silently absorb the devastating account of the loss of a foetus. Stack understands her audience and manipulates its emotional responses with extraordinary skill, shifting effortlessly from laughter to grief with little more than a sideways glance or the inclination of her head.

The premise is deceptively simple. Drawing upon the writings of Sylvia Plath, Virginia Woolf, Emily Dickinson and numerous other women, Stack explores the contradictory human desires for solitude and companionship. Yet this is no illustrated lecture, nor should it be pigeonholed simply as feminist theatre. Its themes are far more universal, and its theatrical language considerably more sophisticated.

Visually, the production is breathtaking.

Stack appears in a simple white dress against a largely monochromatic background upon which quotations from the past are cast. The effect is almost film noir, a world of black, white, shadow and projected text. Eoin Winning’s exquisite lighting design works in perfect harmony with the imagery and motion graphics, creating compositions of remarkable beauty, and stillness.

At one point Stack stands at the front of the intimate Traverse 2 space, her face bisected by a projected beam. The lower half, illuminated just below the nose, is inscribed with words, while the upper half disappears into darkness. It is an extraordinary image, almost a surgical incision into the identity of the woman before us, revealing and concealing her simultaneously.

Elsewhere, the projections wash across her white dress, transforming her body into a living canvas. The quotations are no longer merely words from the past; they become physical impressions upon the performer herself.

There is something of the monoprint about this process. An image transferred from one surface to another is inevitably altered, acquiring new textures, shadows and meanings. Stack achieves something similar with these historical quotations, transferring them through her own experiences and allowing them to become something fresh, immediate and intensely personal.

The almost complete absence of colour makes its occasional appearance all the more powerful. At the midpoint, Stack is suddenly washed in a gorgeous pale blue as the word ALONE dominates the screen behind her. The colour of sky blue optimism. Within it she identifies ALL and ONE, a beautifully economical manipulation of language and colour which encapsulates the central paradox of the performance.

The staging is equally assured. Stack moves between a microphone stage right, the open central space without amplification and the projection-lit area downstage left area. Each position establishes a different relationship with the audience. Her vocal tone shifts accordingly, from the controlled delivery of a lecturer to the intimacy of a confession, and occasionally to the mischievous timing of a stand-up comedian.

And she is very funny.

With what feels like a very appropriate Irish lilt and perfectly judged pauses and sudden changes of expression she punctures the philosophical seriousness with delightful irreverence. The humour never feels imposed upon the material; it emerges naturally from the contradictions of human behaviour.

Particularly affecting are the references to her sister. Following the loss of a pregnancy, her sister offers her a lump of cheese, a gesture at once absurd, inadequate but ultimately tasty. Later comes the suggestion from her sibling that perhaps she should spend less time contemplating the nihilism of Sylvia Plath and more time going out, partying and dancing.

And dance she does.

These unexpected eruptions of movement interrupt the intellectual discourse with a joyous physicality, reminding us that life is not something to be understood exclusively through books, quotations or philosophical reflection. Sometimes it simply needs to be lived.

There are echoes here of Batshit, the Australian solo production seen at the Edinburgh Fringe, in the blending of personal history, humour and wider questions about women’s lives. But No Woman Is an Island possesses a visual and theatrical identity entirely its own.

What makes this production exceptional is its absolute control of form. Nothing feels accidental. The lighting, projection, movement, sound and spoken word are not competing theatrical devices but elements of a single, beautifully integrated composition.

Stack has created a work that is intellectually stimulating without becoming pretentious, emotionally affecting without sentimentality, and frequently hilarious without undermining its seriousness.

Fitzgerald’s boats may be forever struggling against the current, but here the voices of the past are not simply pulling us backwards. Through Stack’s remarkable performance, they are carried forward, transformed and given renewed life.

An extraordinary, intelligent and visually exquisite work of art.

Reviewer: Greg Holstead

Reviewed: 14th November 2026

North West End UK Rating:

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Running time – 1hr

0Shares