This week, Joseph Stalin came to life and set to work on authoring a play on his own life in a dark room beneath the Kremlin, whilst his originally selected writer of choice took over state matters in return. And everything went exactly as you’d expect! Sheffield University Theatre Company (SUTCo)’s ‘Collaborators’ was a pretty good version of the award-winning John Hodge satire as it took to the stage at Uni Central in Sheffield.

Hodge’s text is silly, scathing and deeply sincere in its ridiculing rebukes. It’s a great selection of play – one which, despite the somewhat contentious yet well-intentioned comparisons to brutal, oppressive governmental rule in the West, still rings through with a degree of alarming resonance. Many of the performances in this production are commendable. Amir Ali offers a persuasive and competent performance as the anti-hero Mikhail Bulgakov. Sam Blake’s Vladimir, whilst being a bit panto-villain at times, was ultimately bright and forthcoming. Emma Garde and Alex Mackie execute their roles well, with Daniel Spence also being fun to watch. Freddie Dunton’s Stalin was particularly excellent – whilst a challenging role, Dunton handled it with aplomb; possessing a thoughtful, lyrical physicality and accomplished verbal nuance.
The play is directed by Kate Fletcher and Ade Ingram and whilst there is plenty to admire in their work, it ultimately felt a little metronomic and lacking in some attention to detail in places. The attention to detail marker is a tough one – there’s no escaping this production company is made up of students with different focuses and ambitions at such a pivotal stage of their young adulthood. They cannot be compared to or treated like professional creatives who have the time and ability to put 110% to the project at hand. That said, it would be unjust to patronise these talented, determined young people who have given an awful lot to this production – to write off areas that could be improved upon in this theatrical venture is to not take them seriously and we should. They were really committed, showed flashes of brilliance, were playful and keen-spirited. Yet I felt they could be even better than they were with a bit more detail in their performances and creative decision-making. The creative team, cast and crew can help us believe the characters and become immersed in the world by allowing themselves to disappear within it a little more – as at times it felt a bit too explicitly like students putting on a play. For example, the play is quite rich with choreographed dance sequences between characters. An intimate act, undeniably. These dances, however, are quite rigid and unconvincing. There is a physical awkwardness which again can be forgiven in the context of young people working together in a show, but to commit to the characters is to commit to their relationships. We are denied the tenderness of these moments – and crucially denied the the significance of them – through slightly stiff and clumsy physical contact. This is not isolated to dance sequences either. There is an overarching theme of distance between the performers and their characters, and subsequently between the characters themselves within the text and this is felt by the audience.
That said, there can be some mitigation in the fact that this is unapologetically black box theatre. Yes, there is a set, but it is rigid, simple and functional – actually clever even – and the show is better for this. Everything else, proxemics, staging, is all very black box fringe theatre. It’s admirable in places, with no need to try and trick the audience into some grand environmental transportation; allowing the text and characters to redraw scenes, but this is still sometimes inconsistent. Gunshots are interpretive and symbolic, with the falling back and lifting of one of the characters as they are assassinated. It’s a point of brutality that is designed to be sharp, but this particular demonstration blunts its impact. Then, in the climax, a gunshot becomes real and present – a loud bang, blood stained shirt etc. This inconsistency doesn’t make either creative event bad in itself, but it challenges the lens of the world we are invited into in an unhelpful manner. We aren’t dealing Brechtian alienation, but there is a theatrical style that flirts with the symbolic and interpretative so much that the oscillation of the two becomes distracting and a little bit incoherent.
But these detailed areas that leave a little to be desired are simply pockets and marks on an extensive theatrical tapestry that was inviting and entertaining to gaze upon. SUTCo have demonstrated they have great taste, great ambition and I’m excited to see what they have to offer next.
Reviewer: Nathan Dunn
Reviewed: 18th November 2026
North West End UK Rating: