The most persuasive argument ‘Sylvia’ makes at the Royal Albert Hall comes from its cast, they sing with conviction, dance with precision and bring personality to a musical that too often gives them history to deliver where there ought to be drama. The struggle for women’s suffrage, and the divisions within the Pankhurst family over how to pursue it, offer the material for a gripping evening. Here, the effort to fit so much of that history into one show makes for a long and surprisingly monotonous one.
Kate Prince, who wrote the lyrics and co-wrote the book with Priya Parmar, gives scarcely a development room to pass without a number. Several songs could easily go without losing anything essential, and their absence might give the better ones a chance to register with the audience. The production feels close to three hours, and the problem is as much about emphasis as length. When so many historical events are given the same weight, it becomes harder to feel the consequences of the choices that divide Sylvia and Emmeline.
The hip-hop styling is ambitious, but the score by Josh Cohen and DJ Walde rarely finds enough light and shade. And of course, the comparisons with Hamilton and Six are hard to shake. Hamilton uses rap to sharpen political rivalries, while Six gives each of its queens a distinct musical identity. In ‘Sylvia’ however, too many numbers make their point at the same pitch of urgency. The rhythms keep the performers moving, but the songs seldom reveal enough about the people singing them. Even the most urgent arguments lose their force when the music gives them so little room to breathe and the audience opportunity to hear the lyrics.

Beverley Knight is of course exceptional as Emmeline Pankhurst. Her vocal authority is formidable, and she gives Emmeline the presence of someone accustomed to being heard. Naomi Katiyo is equally strong as Sylvia, finding a different kind of resolve in a daughter whose convictions take her away from her mother. The difference between them is more compelling than much of the material around them. Across the ensemble, the standard is remarkably high, and these are accomplished vocalists, hip-hop dancers and actors, often called on to show all three skills in the space of a single number. They make that demand look effortless.
With relatively little physical scenery on the Royal Albert Hall stage, Natasha Chivers and Hector Murray use lighting to give scenes shape and focus. Ben Stones’ costumes are equally well judged, carrying recognisable period silhouettes into the modern visual language of the choreography. There is a clarity to those design choices that Prince’s writing could use. Both know how much detail a moment needs and when to let the performers hold the eye.
‘Sylvia’ takes on questions of voting rights and equality that deserve a full-blooded musical treatment. A firmer edit would give the family conflict room to develop and let the score vary its pace as the stakes change. What stays with me is the conviction Knight and Katiyo bring to two women whose shared cause could pull them so far apart. I just wanted to spend more of the evening with those two women without all the unnecessary noise.
Reviewer: Alan Stuart Malin
Reviewed: 13th November 2026
North West End UK Rating: