I was excited to set foot in the fabulous Blacks on Dean Street, a private members club that was much frequented by yours truly in the ‘90s. Originally built in 1732 by the apprentice to Christopher Wren, the Georgian townhouse became a supper club in 1764, hosted by Dr Samuel Johnson, artist Joshua Reynolds and playwright David Garrick. The 18th-century painter William Hogarth was not only a member of Blacks but often paid for his meals in prints, which until recently adorned the walls of this historic space.

Notorious poacher and gastronomic bad boy Tom Bantock took over the club in 1992. He turned it into a debauched alternative to White’s Club, London’s oldest and stuffiest Gentleman’s Club. Blacks was full-on goth, quirkily bohemian and echoed the wild days of Soho when drugs, sex, and crime were valid pursuits for artists and intellectuals. Under Bantock, Blacks served excellent food and shadowy fun. It often felt like a haunted house party where you might end up injecting coke with Nick Cave or sharing liquid eyeliner with Siouxsie Sioux.
In a tragic reflection of modern times, Roger Payne and Luke Thomas sold the club in 2022 to a cryptocurrency firm. The Bitcoin bros hoped to expand into the neighbouring property and open a satellite venue in Dubai. This spiritual death was followed by genuine mortality. In 2023, Blacks announced its closure. Mysteriously, it’s open again, and appears to be a rentable venue for events and a part-time bijou performance space. Launching this suspicious venture is Grit, Glitter and Gaslight- The Sarah McGuinness Story, which might be the strangest show you can see in a 260-year-old townhouse.
McGuinness embraces the theatrical conventions of tawdry cabaret. The stage is a tiny, cluttered dressing room. She’s dressed like Sally Bowles with a dash of Madonna. With a showbiz dark bob and wide-eyed drama, she regales the audience with stories of her challenging childhood. The move from London to the city of Derry in Northern Ireland as The Troubles erupted in the 1970s can’t have been easy. While McGuinness gives some insight into the brutal civil war spilling onto the streets around her, the focus is kept firmly on her own Troubles. She was bullied for her English accent, unappreciated by her parents and left to roam the streets unsupervised. Welcome to the 1970s.
David Bowie descended like Jesus into bombed out Derry, via a library cassette. His genderfluid oddity gave McGuinness hope and inspiration. Like he did to millions of sad teens and ostracised adults, including this one. McGuinness then launches into a superb version of Life on Mars from Hunky Dory. It’s an interpretation, rather than a loyal cover, but it’s an epic tribute to the Thin Duke. Her gorgeous singing voice is an unfortunate tonic to her hard luck story. One is left wanting more of that and less of the self-pitying narrative that she returns to with thin-skinned gusto. McGuinness seems to be still furious about a childhood that anyone from the ‘70s might view as standard. Being terrorised by the British Army or the IRA is the most unique part of her story, but she fails to mine that rich seam adequately.
As the show dragged on, part of me was silently begging her to drop the victim vibes and laugh at herself. Infuriatingly, she hints at brushes with celebrity and iconic talent, as the story sees her return to London to pursue a career in music. The Showbiz Lifestory is such a well-worn theatre trope that nowadays, it’s usually presented as parody, a comic monologue of unlikely namedrops and dishonest accolades. In a bizarre about turn, she skips over or hides her impressive creative achievements and serves almost zero showbiz anecdotes. McGuinness has PLENTY, so why is she hiding them?
Her first single Mandy Says, was produced by John O’Neill of the Undertones and while managing a London comedy club, she launched the careers of Jenny Éclair and Ardal O’Hanlon. Her 2012 single Mama Can You See Me Now, was a cult hit in America and remixed by dance wizard William Orbit (RIP). She was Emmy-nominated for the film Believe: The Eddie Izzard Story and walked the red carpet at the LA awards ceremony. She dated Izzard for some time and composed the music for his videos for 14 years. Her solo album solo features tracks produced by Ed Buller (Suede) and Mickey Petralia (Beck). None of this is mentioned. No names. No dish. No scandal. No colourful despatches from the front line of alternative comedy and the drug fuelled indie music scene? Her ‘story’ that she wants us to believe is one of missed opportunities, unjust failure and a lack of recognition. Sarah?! Her CV says otherwise.
She also operates under the name Sarah Townsend (with blonde curly hair) AND DOESN’T REVEAL ANY OF THIS, despite the fact that due to the Internet, one doesn’t have to be Poirot to work out her double identity and theatrical sleight of hand. It’s a damn shame because she’s had a rich and creative life Her career is filled with fascinating characters, and possibly some unwise choices, but she has no right to complain or seek sympathy. Which is all she does, while occasionally blessing us with her gorgeous voice. At one point she belts out an a capella Irish ballad. Not only does it bring a tear to my eye, her tone raises Celtic ghosts and causes cracks in Connemara marble, deep in the mountains of Galway. It’s incredible.
At one point, she slipped from the stage and fell face first into my lap. She pulled herself up, didn’t miss a beat and was obviously mortified. I truly felt for her in that moment, because it was a woeful mishap, but it was also possibly the most revealing and authentic part of the show.
Grit, Glitter and Gaslight is at Blacks until 6th December,
Blacks Club | Now available for private bookings
Reviewer: Stewart Who?
Reviewed: 13th November 2026
North West End UK Rating: