“Inspired by the true story Punch” this production at the Apollo Theatre features a small but impressive cast of six and production team credited for bringing this life story to the West End stage.
The staging is set to resemble a dark place for a conclave, on the steps, the bridge and on stage which enabled an astonishing style of creative movement, as the actors moved freely and smoothly from character to character, to scene change in synchronised motion. Credit to Leanne Pinder the movement was so emotionally moving aligning with the tragedy and empathy, which I’m sure was felt very strongly by the audience, just WOW. Scenes with strobe and flashing lights, the play has references to violence, death, alcohol and substance misuse.
What strikes you in the opening scenes of this play is the actor’s attention to detail and the didactic approach of the narrative. If you are not familiar with the real-life story of ‘One Punch’ and the power of restorative justice, you certainly will be when you leave. This meaningful, impactful dramatisation of James Hodgkinson and Jacob Dunne fate after a night out which led to devastating consequences not only for them, but for the lives of their families.
Jacob played by the intrepid David Shields ‘kicks off’ literally his life living in Nottingham on the Meadows estate, in with the wrong crowd, drinking, drug taking and looking for a fight was his common place. Julie Hesmondhalgh known for her roles as Haley Cropper in Coronation Street and Mr Bates vs The Post Office is the formidable Joan, James’ mother who through strength and courage is looking for a resolution to how she is feeling and how she can change how she feels about Jacob. There are many outstanding convincing performances by Tony Hirst James, father, and gang member, Emma Pallant Jacob’s mum, her torment and life struggles was palpable, Sam and Raf, Alec Boaden, Shalisha James – Davis added a unique individuality to every element of their roles.
There are moments of laughter, theatrical professionalism and strong language lots of expletives reflecting the gritty characteristics of Jacob and his life. The humour offered some light relief from the heaviness, which was welcomed, demonstrating the brilliance of the writing.
Act two you could hear a pin drop as the restorative justice scene unfolded with open heartbreaking realism. Tears and gut-wrenching sadness emanated from the stage and reciprocated back by the audience. To be in a situation confronted by the killer of your son is unimaginable, as the victim’s family search for answers. This scene is a moment in time to reflect, understand and make sense of how in an instant a life can be changed; and engage with the methodology of restorative justice offering a ‘chance’ to heal, move forward and help others. A bold move to bring this process to the stage due to its emotive purpose. Did it work yes, the actor’s respectful portrayal of PUNCH provoked a response of visible emotion right across the theatre.
PUNCH is Powerful Unbelievably Numbing with a Creative History that will Impact all who see it. A remarkable story brought to life by James Graham in the memory of one James Hodgkinson.
By James Graham & Based on the Book Right From Wrong by Jacob Dunne
Dedicated in Memory to James Hodgkinson
Director Adam Penford
Production Designer Anna Fleischle
Lighting Designer Robbie Butler
Sound Designer & Composer Alexandra Faye Braithwaite
Movement Director Leanne Pinder
This show commences at 7.00pm or 7.30pm check the daily timings approximately 2hrs and 25minutes, including a 20minute interval
Runs, 22nd September – 29th November 2025
Booking Link https://theapollotheatre.co.uk/tickets/punch
Reviewer: Michelle Knight
Reviewed: 26th September 2025
North West End UK Rating