Yorkshire & Humber

The Panic Room – The Octagon

‘The Panic Room’ aimed to bring an unsettling, anxious atmosphere to the Octagon last night. With a show heavily focused on mental health, grief and denial, I left thinking the production needs further revisions to accurately portray these sensitive themes and bring a concept to life. Led by co-directors and choreographers James Pett and Travis Clausen-Knight (founders of the internationally acclaimed PCK Dance), ‘The Panic Room’ is a mixed bag, with weaker moments, but also some wonderful arrangements.

The dance follows John, a writer, who is hounded by his Publisher and Editor to complete the ending of a book he’s been working on. The events of the book blur the boundary between fiction and reality, obscuring its true origin story and conclusion. As John works himself to exhaustion, he faces distress and restlessness, juggling it with a deep despair. It begs the question: does changing a story’s narrative truly solve a seemingly inevitable outcome?

The performers themselves did a well-rounded job with the material provided. The movements were consistently fluid and overall pleasant to watch. Additionally, the show itself is quite long, and the dancers constantly moving displayed a high level of agility and stamina, which was impressive. Of the four dancers, I enjoyed Isabelle Evans as Chloe the most. Her dance featured several stellar moments, particularly within the final scenes when the twist is revealed. James Pett as John also put on a show, with deep tension and overwhelm seeping through his every move. Travis Clausen-Knight as The Publisher and Amy McEntee as The Editor are well-suited to the roles, with Clausen-Knight’s portrayal featuring plenty of sass and McEntee’s being very elegant and crisp. My main criticism of the cast is that their performances falter when the lights are off or when they’re “off-stage” – where, importantly, audiences can still see them – as they seem to break character or put less heart into it. Although the dancers’ ability to keep in time, sometimes in complete silence, was sophisticated.

Oliver Pett’s set design was minimal, with white screens that moved around the stage, their shape being manipulated by the cast, a wooden table and chairs and paper strewn around the floor. Beyond anything, I was more worried about the performers’ safety, as they frequently stood on and slipped on the paper. The screens were a charming feature when puppetry and shadow-work were used, but otherwise the “walls caving in” imagery seemed on-the-nose, and their movement across the stage seemed laborious and hindering for the actors.

Sean Pett’s composition was the strongest element of the show. The zen music and ambient sounds aided it, and the voiceovers helped to drive the story forward. I particularly liked the rain effects throughout the play and the synergy between the actors’ lines and the sound design. However, some parts were dynamically out of place. I found some lines and sounds were so quiet and muffled I couldn’t make them out, and others were so overpowering my ears began to ring. Although I do understand this could be the result of other external factors, it made the watching experience overstimulating.

‘The Panic Room’ felt more like observing an avant-garde art museum exhibit than a theatrical performance. The first act felt whole, and only the last handful of minutes from the second act felt relevant to the plot, with the rest feeling confusing and repetitive. From my understanding, the second act is reflective of different characters morphing into one another and the concept of identity, but to an audience who haven’t got enough context or clarity, this feels too drawn-out, experimental and niche. The idea behind the show itself is a strong one, drawing plenty of similarities to human experiences with mental illness and sorrow, but it left a taste of “GCSE Drama” in my mouth.

‘The Panic Room’, presented by PCK Dance, is part of the Enable US programme in Sheffield this Autumn and Winter season. The programme also features international dance, theatre and workshops, with the press release being available here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1LB1Ql05eETU9908eiPJAuK8cX8IfUUR631oNYTC-uIk/edit?usp=drivesdk  

Reviewer: Natalia Prucnal

Reviewed: 16th November 2026

North West End UK Rating:

Rating: 2 out of 5.

Natalia Prucnal

Recent Posts

Annie – The Brindley

There are productions that entertain, and then there are productions that leave you walking out…

60 minutes ago

No Woman Is An Island – Traverse Theatre

So, we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past F.…

13 hours ago

Anatomy of Survival – Stanley Arts

Music, dance, and a frayed nervous system are at the heart of this play about…

13 hours ago

Blackadder Goes Forth – Altrincham Garrick Playhouse

Every once in a while, a production comes along which reminds you just how good…

13 hours ago

Mrs Doubtfire – Leeds Grand Theatre

Last night I had the delight to be invited back along to Leeds Grand Theatre…

1 day ago

Manchester Musical Youth 12th Anniversary Concert – Z-Arts

A spectacular anniversary concert at Z-arts showcased the remarkable talent, passion and community spirit that…

1 day ago