Scotland

Elf Lyons is The Woman on the Edge – Pleasance Courtyard

Elf Lyons is The Woman on the Edge arrived with considerable expectation, and for a while I thought I was in for something rather special.

The opening Hitchcock-esque passages are beautifully conceived, Lyons creating something strange, textured and nuanced, with an unsettling film-noir quality that suggested an intriguing hour ahead. Unfortunately, for me, the show gradually lost its way.

The Beyond at Pleasance Courtyard doesn’t necessarily help. It is a particularly wide room, requiring Lyons to cover considerable ground to maintain contact with the whole audience. She certainly works hard physically, but looking around during some of the longer passages, I saw rather a lot of people not laughing. Instead, there were quizzical faces, apparently trying, as I was, to piece everything together.

Much of the hour concerns Lyons’s emotional recovery following the breakdown of her engagement. There is anger here, particularly towards men, which is entirely understandable, but anger still has to be transformed into compelling comedy. Too often I found the material thought-provoking rather than funny.

More problematic is the extensive reliance on pre-recorded material and lip-syncing. At one point an audience member is enlisted to read substantial passages while Lyons performs alongside them. These devices may be intended to fracture the storytelling, but I increasingly found myself wanting Lyons herself back.

For me, the show became something of a theatrical desert punctuated by the occasional oasis.

Then there is Apollo 13. Lyons draws a parallel between the stricken spacecraft, Mission Control guiding its crew home and the friends and family who helped her navigate her own emotional crisis. I understand the intended connection. I simply didn’t believe in it dramatically. Rather than growing organically from the story, Apollo 13 felt stapled onto its side.

There is clearly ambition here, alongside clowning, mime, opera, film references and intensely personal material. But accumulating theatrical ideas does not necessarily create coherence.

Perhaps, after 75 Fringe reviews, I expected too much from my final show before returning to the day job. I certainly hoped to leave uplifted. Instead, I left somewhat deflated. There are moments of joy in The Woman on the Edge, and its opening promised something strange and rather wonderful. Lyons undoubtedly has something to say. I just wish she had found a more coherent, and considerably funnier, way of saying it.

Playing until August 31^st 2026, https://www.edfringe.com/tickets/whats-on/2026ELFLYON

Reviewer: Greg Holstead

Reviewed: 23rd August 2026

North West End UK / Theatre Muse UK Rating: