Photo: Marc Brenner
Eugene O’Neill’s take on a Greek tragedy is an irresistible prospect and rather timely, as London theatre continues to revisit Ancient Greece for its timeless tales of tragedy. This punchy and dynamic production is far from subtle and will not be to everyone’s taste, with its big swings and big emotions on display. But Greek tragedy ever was thus, with its shocking twists and taboo subject matter.
Written in 1924, Desire Under the Elms is one of O’Neill’s lesser-performed works, once again exploring an unhappy family dynamic, but this time based on the story of Phaedra, with influences also taken from Medea. O’Neill originally set the drama in 1850s New England, but director Ebenezer Bamgboye has now transposed the action to the American Deep South in 1900, gorgeously lit from above with a rich orange glow bearing down like still heat and, later, by shards of ice-cold blue light penetrating upwards through the concrete floor to great effect in Jack Knowles’ masterful lighting design.
Here we find three brothers fighting over who will ultimately inherit the family farm. Leading man Eben quickly pays off his two half-brothers, leaving him as sole heir and leaving only his violent stepfather Ephraim as the obstacle to regaining his late mother’s land. Casting Eben as an African American man brings an additional dimension to the story, raising questions about whether the land was taken illegitimately by Ephraim from Eben’s late mother, who haunts his dreams through the stunning vocals of Choolwe Laina Muntanga. Alongside fellow musician-actors Tendai Humphrey Sitima and Nathaniel Wade, these “spirits” stalk Basia Bińkowska’s concrete stage, moving along the catwalks that frame it and between the rows of audience seating that surround it. This breaking of the fourth wall establishes an ominous tone from the very start, instilling in the audience a sense that nothing is off limits as the cast run between us with growing intensity, daring us to look away.
At times, this device risks being overused, but it is one of several examples of Bamgboye utilising the space to sustain the momentum of a text that would otherwise benefit from a slight trim at two hours and forty minutes.
Movement is one of the key creative choices in this production, and movement and intimacy director Rose Ryan does an excellent job working closely with Zackary Momoh’s Eben to instil him with a physical vocabulary that feels both precise and instinctive. His balletic stretches are elegant and measured, floating around the space like a boxer, marking his territory with his own spit. He is a magnetic presence, a ball of anxious energy just waiting to explode. He is matched for intensity by Antony Byrne as his stepfather Ephraim, whose Shakespearean heritage serves him well. Byrne’s presence dominates every scene through unpredictable bursts of violence that shock and unsettle.
However, it is Kelly Gough, the real-life sister of Denise Gough, who is ultimately in control here. Gough is mesmerising as Abbie, Ephraim’s new young wife, a malevolent presence with a feline-like prowl, her eyes set firmly on the farm and living up to Eben’s description of her as a “manipulative trickster”. Her slow-motion intimacy scenes with Eben a particular highlight. Beneath a wicked smile is a she-devil, cruelly using her infant child as a pawn between the two men who love her. While there is a horrendous inevitability to how far her dark heart will go to fulfil her will, it is her final realisation of the consequences of her actions that delivers a gut punch of epic proportions. Gough truly delivers one of the standout theatrical performances of the year.
This production won’t be for everybody, as the tone steadily darkens and, for some, will prove too much to stomach as the tragic motifs reach their conclusion. For a playwright whose work can sometimes feel like an endurance test, this is a gripping, taut and excellently conceived piece.
Desire Under the Elms continues at the Almeida Theatre until Wednesday 23rd December. Details can be found here: Desire Under the Elms | Almeida Theatre
Reviewer: Phil Meikle
Reviewed: 19th November 2026
North West End UK Rating:
After last year’s Christmas parody Lovers Actually broke sales records for The Other Palace Studio,…
This week, Joseph Stalin came to life and set to work on authoring a play…
Written by Joe Ward Munrow, Liverpool Everyman are back with their famous Rock ‘n’ Roll…
Written by and starring Stephanie Greenwood, Relative Motion examines a burgeoning relationship through the lens…
Things are going bump in the night at The Lowry this week, as Paranormal Activity…
Even though it was a Tuesday, my friend and I could only wear pink for…