Why Am I So Single? – Garrick Theatre

Brand new to the West End, and from the writers of the ever-growing popular musical “Six”, comes this story within a story answering the burning question for those singletons in their twenties: “Why Am I So Single?”

From the opening, it is clear what this show intends to be. With its Brechtian set up and constant breaking of the fourth wall, this show is immersive from the off. Particularly clever is the role the ensemble takes on throughout the performance, most notably as parts of the furniture in the stylish flat. Aside from being comically hilarious as the pieces of furniture join in and become a part of the action on stage, the actors perform their roles artistically and cleverly, evoking plenty of laughter.

The talent of the cast is bursting at the seams. The ensemble moves effortlessly on the stage, entirely in sync with every movement and giving their highest energy to each motion. The dance numbers are particularly special and uplifting in this production but paired with extraordinary vocals from Jo Foster who plays Oliver and Leesa Tulley who plays Nancy, these scenes are particularly enjoyable. Though the score isn’t particularly memorable, the songs are placed well and complement the anecdotes the actors are trying to portray. Tulley performed a surprisingly emotional solo “Just In Case” and managed to make quite a basic song lyrically become a strong and heartfelt ballad. Foster is a compelling presence at all times and a captivating watch. Their ability to switch up their characters vocally and physically showcase their talent and makes them a perfect casting choice to keep the audience engaged.

A standout scene is where Nancy and Artie, played by Noah Thomas, are on stage together. Thomas’ rhythmic timing and expert line delivery create a perfect comedically timed scene, but the real surprise comes when the ensemble begin to tap dance. Entirely unexpected, the tap dancing and hip-hop style dance combination is a real crowd pleaser and these actors mould faultlessly into this genre.

The premise of this show is not revolutionary as it surrounds two friends having a natter on the sofa and so the set does not need to be groundbreaking. However, its simplicity creates a comfortable and cosy flat which produces a warm setting for the audience to feel like the two leads on stage are having a conversation directly with you.

Square windows at the back of the stage help to create an intimate feel with the rims lighting up and changing colour in line with the chaos on stage, creating effective scene transitions particularly into an instrumental anecdote. Props are used well throughout, especially in the number “Meat Market” where pink trollies help capture the likeness between dating apps and grocery shopping. It is always special when the orchestra can be seen during a performance, but the band in this production are above the stage making them feel omnipresent but adding to the intimate staging.

This show has a clear target audience. From its pop culture references to battling prominent issues in today’s society, this musical will appeal mostly to a certain bracket of people, although there is enough artistry and entertainment to make it enjoyable for all. With excellent casting, choreography and bursting with infectious energy, this performance is sure to trigger your emotions, both jubilant and sentimental. Go alone or grab a friend and strap yourself in for a night of fabulous contemporary theatre.

Why Am I So Single? is currently playing at the Garrick Theatre until 13th February 2025 with more information and tickets to be found at: https://whyamisosingle.com/

Reviewer: Maani Way

Reviewed: 10th September 2024

North West End UK Rating: