The Shatter Box, written by James Lewis and directed by David Brady, comes with a promising premise. Set in a dystopian world, a man awakens in a cage inside a mysterious facility. His captors probe him for the truth, though they themselves seem unsure of what they’re seeking. The cage will only open when he provides the right answer. This intriguing setup, blending themes of ethics, scientific exploration and human consciousness, should generate gripping drama, but unfortunately falls short of its potential.
At the heart of the story are four main characters: the prisoner (Fred Wardale), the examiner (Gabrielle Nellis-Pain), the guard (Nick Hardie), and the carer (Lauren Ferdinand). Despite life-and-death stakes, their performances generally lack the urgency needed. Wardale’s portrayal feels one-dimensional, a character trapped not just in a cage but in a monotonous delivery. Nellis-Pain, though initially promising with a vocal print reminiscent of Fiona Shaw in Killing Eve, loses impact, her authority diminished by over-reliance on props and a power suit. Her hesitant physicality—circling aimlessly and stepping back from the cage—further weakens her presence. Hardie, however, stands out, revelling in his character’s cold detachment and underlying streak of sadism.
The play’s biggest challenges stem from the text itself though. The dialogue, often repetitive, weakens the narrative’s flow, turning this Shatter Box into an overwritten chatterbox where not much happens or only too late. With much of the text directed at the audience, meaningful character interactions are limited. By the time the final plot twist arrives, it feels underdeveloped, its subtle foreshadowing buried beneath the incessant verbiage.
Ultimately, The Shatter Box plays it too safe for a production dealing with such vivid themes. What could have been a searing examination of human consciousness and morality in times of excessive rationalisation instead feels more like a talk-heavy reflection, better suited to radio than the stage.
Reviewer: Klervi Gavet
Reviewed: 12th September 2024
North West End UK Rating:
Based on the 1988 movie, Heathers the Musical has come exploding in to the Storyhouse,…
The Global sensation of Steven Knight’s’ Peaky Blinders took TV audiences by storm and not…
There’s been plenty of novels about the First World War, but Sebastian Faulks’s Birdsong was…
Michael Flatley’s Lord of the Dance latest touring show ‘A Lifetime of Standing Ovations’ is…
It’s hard to believe two decades have passed since the late, great Richard Griffiths first…
The Prudes, written by Anthony Neilson, is a comedy centred around the sex lives (or…