Yorkshire & Humber

Nativity! The Musical – Sheffield Lyceum

The primary school nativity play is something most of us have experienced. We were either in one, or we have watched someone else in one, or maybe even both! Following the plot of the hit 2009 Christmas comedy film of the same name, Nativity! shares the experience of the kids from St Bernadette’s, as they get ready for their annual performance, alongside their dejected and heartbroken teacher, Mr Maddens, and their energetic new classroom assistant, Mr Poppy. And energetic is a description that you could rightly extend to this whole production!

Yes, this is a feel-good, happy-ending story, bursting with passion and energy, but it is so much more than that. The story also urges us all to look inside ourselves. What makes you happy? What rivalries are you chasing and where are they rooted? What is the impact of our words on others? What does it take to change? The material is excellent; the book by Debbie Isitt provides hilarious one-liners and physical comedy alongside heartwarming pep talks and vulnerable moments. However good a book is, though, you need the performers to carry it off; and carry it off they did.

STOS Theatre Company, now in it’s 126th year, has gathered an outstanding cast of adults and children alike. There are 48 children (split into two groups) performing in this production, and I was blown away by their talent and their obvious joy in performing. The children, especially those playing St. Bernadette’s students, spent huge chunks of time on stage, and moved smoothly between choreographed dance and movement, powerhouse vocals and authentic portrayal of all kinds of situations. It would not be fair to praise one child over any other, but if these kids are the future of musical theatre, it is in safe hands!

Photo: Roe-Parkin Creative

The adult cast members were equally capable, all working hard to bring authenticity to their various roles and nailing the comedy timing. A particular mention must go to Sam Widdowson as Mr Poppy, whose boundless enthusiasm rubbed off on every scene partner. However, it was his moments of self-doubt and vulnerability that cemented this as an outstanding performance and Widdowson can only be commended for riding that emotional rollercoaster through every second of the show.

Director Keeley Kilby has clearly worked exceedingly hard to pull together such a slick production. The show is well-paced and hits every comedy highlight. Choreographer Katie Granger had her work cut out with such a large cast of adults and children, and the result is slick, professional and extremely effective. It was also a delight to see an amateur production with a six-piece live band (managed by musical director Dominic Ridler). Finally, turning to the set design, I’m not typically a fan of a digital backdrop, but I do understand the logic of using one for a show like this – as it facilitates quick changes of location without constantly having to move scenery or furniture.

Does this production sparkle and shine? Absolutely!

It is the perfect way to kick off this Christmas season.

Nativity! The Musical continues at the Lyceum Theatre in Sheffield until Saturday 21st November 2026. More details and ticket information can be found on the website: https://www.sheffieldtheatres.co.uk/. More information about STOS Theatre Company, including how to get involved in future productions, can be found on their website: https://stos.org.uk/.

Reviewer: Jo Tillotson

Reviewed: 17th November 2026

North West End UK Rating:

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Jo Tillotson

Recent Posts

Relative Motion – Southwark Playhouse

Written by and starring Stephanie Greenwood, Relative Motion examines a burgeoning relationship through the lens…

3 hours ago

Paranormal Activity – The Lowry

Things are going bump in the night at The Lowry this week, as Paranormal Activity…

3 hours ago

Mean Girls: The Musical – Edinburgh Playhouse

Even though it was a Tuesday, my friend and I could only wear pink for…

3 hours ago

Legally Blonde – Regent Theatre

OMIGOD YOU GUYS! The Regent Theatre has become ‘the hallowed halls of Harvard Law’ for…

4 hours ago

Annie – The Brindley

There are productions that entertain, and then there are productions that leave you walking out…

19 hours ago

The Panic Room – The Octagon

‘The Panic Room’ aimed to bring an unsettling, anxious atmosphere to the Octagon last night.…

20 hours ago