Following the success of their returning production Wish You Were Here, Without Compromise Theatre brings its second show to the Edinburgh Fringe with the gritty and gut-wrenching Derby Day. Set in Fife, the play examines the aftermath of a fatal stabbing through the eyes of friends Danny (Xander Cowan) and Harris (Kieran Lee-Hamilton). As the investigation unfolds, the two attempt to distance themselves from any connection to the deceased. Yet the harder they try to conceal the truth, the more it inevitably seeps through the cracks.
Written by Michael Johnson, Derby Day explores themes of cyclical violence and abuse within the framework of a Scottish community. In doing so, it remains true to Without Compromise Theatre’s mission: to advocate for the Scottish working class while exposing the flaws of the system they live within.
Cowan delivers an exceptional performance, embodying both the intensity and fragility of Danny with remarkable precision. At first, Danny appears almost blameless, but as the story deepens, his complicity becomes undeniable. Cowan navigates this shift with integrity, drawing us into a journey that moves from denial to acceptance with striking honesty. Alongside him is Jade, Danny’s partner, played by Kirsty Stevenson. Pregnant with their first child, Jade is unaware that Danny will not be there to raise their baby. Stevenson grounds her character with perceptive warmth and steadiness, even when she is kept in the dark. Her scenes radiate compassion, particularly in her interactions with Danny’s sister Chloe (Maria Woodside).
Woodside shines as Chloe, bringing an authenticity that balances unease with flashes of youthful spirit. Her character, shaped by the shadow of her father’s abuse, reveals both resilience and vulnerability in equal measure. Lee-Hamilton rounds out the cast as Harris, caught between supporting Danny’s wishes and doing what he believes is right. His dynamic with Cowan is especially compelling; while Danny exudes raw power, Harris provides a counterweight, holding his ground with nuance and conviction.
Under Lucy Pederson’s direction, the production achieves clarity and precision. Sensitive subject matter is handled with grace, while the staging reflects careful attention to detail. Every element — from cast direction to technical design — feels purposeful and refined. The lighting and sound act as an emotional undercurrent, heightening the tension that constantly threatens to spill over. Subtle shifts in lighting mirror the characters’ emotional states moment by moment, creating an atmosphere that is both immersive and unsettling.Without Compromise are building quite the reputation for themselves, and it’s no surprise when they are continuously and consistently producing theatre of this calibre. Derby Day is incredibly striking and the issues it tackles are not easy to address, but Without Compromise manages to do so both mindfully and artfully with an incredibly strong message.
Derby Day runs until the 23rd of August at theSpace Triplex, with tickets available at https://www.thespaceuk.com/shows/2025/
Reviewer: Jessie Martin
Reviewed: 19th August 2025
North West End UK Rating:
Alaa Shehada’s one man show about growing up in Jenin is a funny and powerful…
Tom Clarkson and Owen Visser have returned with their anarchic Christmas show, The Christmas Thing.…
It’s December and that can only mean one thing: it’s almost Christmas—well, two things, because…
How do you live a life as beautiful as the one that’s in your head?…
Published as a serial between 1836 and 1839, Charles Dickens’ Oliver Twist has undergone a…
When I was a student in London I saw all the big musicals, but for…