Scotland

Cinderella – Portobello Town Hall, Edinburgh

The story of a once beautiful town hall falling into rack and ruin but being saved, just in the nick of time, by the local community sounds like a fairytale, but here we are in the stunning interior of the revitalised Portobello Town Hall and the successful staging of the family favourite pantomime, Cinderella.

Big, bold, colourful and entertaining. This Stage Door Entertainment, production of the timeless classic, could perhaps do with a bit of a reboot, riven as it is with stereotypes and outdated values, but nevertheless, from the reactions of the almost full house, still appears to hit every mark.

Tommie Travers, Musical Director and co-Producer, correctly puts music centre stage, in a show which is jam-packed with banging tunes and great singing, and with a leading lady, Amy Campbell in the titular role, blessed with a stunning voice and a high register, sharp enough to cut a Christmas cake.

Also high in comedy value, often at the expense of localities Kirkcaldy, Niddrie and Prestonpans, perfectly lead by the double act ugly sisters, Wonky and Stonky, Harrison MacNeill and Leo MacNeill, whose gigantic, rugby-player appearance certainly adds to the hilarity. A right pair of bruisers, but with great comic timing!

Prince Charming is played with fresh-faced nativity and world-weary resignation by Martin Mitchell, who wonders what it would like to be ‘normal’. Helping him cheer up and navigate is street-wise man-servant Dandini, played by Ollie Hiemann. Their early number, On My Way, has the crowd rooting for them.

The story of an orphaned girl serving as a maid to her uncaring step mother and two ugly step sisters, but finding escape with the help of her fairy godmother to go to the ball, meet and marry her Prince Charming. The allegory, that only a man can rescue Cinders from her hardship is not exactly progressive, but then again it is a fairytale!

The first act is very nicely paced, Director Lewis Baird getting the story trotting then galloping towards the interval and finishing just perfectly, shortly after the immortal line, ‘I can’t go to the ball, they ate my invite”!, with the inspired choice of song, Unredeemable poignantly and powerfully delivered by Amy Campbell, complete with fake snow effect. Brilliant!

Inevitably, after such a great first half it does get a bit draggy after the interval, and I’m not just talking the ugly sisters, limping towards the inevitably happy ending and tropic panto antics.

Make no mistake, this is a very good production, but given the undoubted talent here, a little braver approach, a modern re-write perhaps, and a live orchestra, you can’t help thinking that this could have been even better. But maybe that’s just me being a grinch!

Playing until 23rd December. https://www.portobellotownhall.org/events

Reviewer: Greg Holstead

Reviewed: 9th December 2023

North West End UK Rating:

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Greg Holstead

Recent Posts

Taming of the Shrew: A Kinky Retelling – Bread and Roses Theatre

Brush up your Shakespeare and begrime your mind ahead of time to wring all possible…

7 hours ago

Barnum: The Circus Musical – New Wimbledon Theatre

Barnum a spectacular show that takes time to find Its rhythm. Matt Rawle is P.T.…

7 hours ago

What The Animals Say – Finborough Theatre

What The Animals Say is the first play written by David Ireland. This production is…

8 hours ago

Othello – HOME Mcr

This striking co-production between Northern Stage, HOME Manchester, Citizens Theatre, and Royal & Derngate delivers…

8 hours ago

Noises Off – The Questors Theatre

Making theatrical chaos look effortless requires extraordinary control and skill, but The Questors’ production of…

8 hours ago

Terminal 2 – 53two

There can be few settings better suited to contemplating life’s bigger questions than the strange…

3 days ago