Photo: Mihaela Bodlovic
Debuting at the 2022 Edinburgh Fringe, this East Yorkshire-based murder mystery (a Hull-dunnit if you will) has been expanded ahead of a second run. It’s knives out in a new, Northern musical that promises slaughter and laughter – at its final destination of Manchester.
Childhood besties and idlers Kathy (Bronté Barbé) and Stella (Rebekah Hinds) share a joint passion for grisly true crime through a podcast that’s about as popular as they are. However, when their favourite author is brutally murdered, the chance to take on a case of their own- and turn ‘Kathy and Stella’s Murder Podcast’ into a sensation- proves too thrilling to pass up.
Kathy and Stella gets off to a flying start, with Jon Brittain’s sweary script evoking lots of belly laughter from the audience. We’re introduced to the titular duo in an opening number that’s both amusing and catchy: everybody is instantly rooting for them. Quick-wit and one-liners keep us engaged.
By the end of act one, pacing slumps to a near-standstill as the protagonists’ inevitable falling out and a hyper-focusing on their flaws has the story in a chokehold. A winning comic musical can of course still have occasional tender moments, but for something with so much black comedy, the humour/pathos balance in this show tips too heavily towards the latter.
Hinds offers a zealous performance of tough-as-nails Stella to which she lends an attention-grabbing voice. Likewise, Barbé brings the quirky, geeky personality of Kathy to the fore with winsome enthusiasm.
The pair enjoys exemplary support from a cut-throat cast: scene-stealing Jodie Jacobs well and truly slays as Felicia by means of a melodramatic demeanour. Meanwhile, TJ Lloyd delights as morgue technician Justin as well as Kathy’s mother.
Though a few of the songs possess a snappy tune and clever lyrics, it is often hard to discern them as one almost immediately leads into the similar-sounding next. Fabian Aloise’s choreography appears to limit itself to the restraints of a Fringe environment, rarely extending beyond scooting around in desk chairs which results in a waste of a sizeable stage.
A gag reliant on aggressive lesbophobia becomes problematic by its third or fourth recurrence.
For an evening of crime-solving camaraderie, Kathy and Stella are on the case.
Kathy and Stella Solve a Murder!continues at HOME in Manchester until 21st October with tickets available from https://homemcr.org/production/kathy-and-stella-solve-a-murder/
Reviewer: Scot Cunningham
Reviewed: 10th October 2023
North West End UK Rating:
I must admit I went into this musical differently to most people around me because,…
From the Isle of Wight, theatre company Deadman, have embarked on a national tour of…
Currently in its UK debut at Hampstead Theatre, Stage Kiss explores the nature of acting…
Actors like nothing more than talking about themselves and their profession, and this wonderful little…
Brecht without being Brechtian, Mother Courage at the Globe is an array of sound and…
Southern Light’s Guys and Dolls arrives at the Festival Theatre with all the confidence and swagger of…